
Molly Pitcher Inn
Best for riverfront weddings, marina access, and family stays with a seasonal outdoor pool and large event spaces.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Molly Pitcher Inn is a classic, riverfront boutique hotel in Red Bank, New Jersey, aimed at families, wedding parties, and guests who want marina access and nearby downtown attractions. Gild Hall, A Thompson Hotel is an upscale Thompson-branded boutique stay in Manhattan’s Financial District for travelers who want compact luxury, walkable access to Wall Street and the South Street Seaport.
Updated

Best for riverfront weddings, marina access, and family stays with a seasonal outdoor pool and large event spaces.

Best for Lower Manhattan access, boutique luxury with Thompson/Hyatt recognition, and business or city-break travelers who want a compact, design-forward hotel.
When Molly Pitcher Inn wins: choose Molly Pitcher Inn if you want river views, an on-site marina and seasonal pool, or if you’re planning a wedding or large event—its waterfront Promenade and multiple ballrooms are set up for groups.
When Gild Hall wins: pick Gild Hall, A Thompson Hotel if you want a centrally located Manhattan base near Wall Street, the Oculus and South Street Seaport, plus a stylish boutique experience backed by the Thompson brand.
Bottom line: Molly Pitcher Inn suits guests seeking waterfront leisure, family amenities and event space outside the city; Gild Hall suits travelers focused on downtown NYC access and upscale city lodging in a compact package.
| Category | Molly Pitcher Inn | Gild Hall, A Thompson Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Classic, colonial-inspired riverfront inn focused on dining, events and marina access | Upscale, design-forward boutique hotel in the Financial District |
| Location | Red Bank, New Jersey — on the Navesink River near downtown shops and theaters | 15 Gold Street, New York, New York — within walking distance of Wall Street and South Street Seaport |
| Size (guest rooms) | 106 guestrooms and suites | 130 guestrooms |
| Audience / age policy | All ages welcome; family-friendly | All ages welcome (property not adults-only) |
| Pool / waterfront | Seasonal outdoor pool overlooking the marina | No on-site pool published |
| Restaurants & bars | The Dining Room (Contemporary American) + International Bar | Felice Restaurante + bar/lounge; limited room service |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa; 24-hour fitness center with Nautilus and cardio equipment | No on-site spa published; health/beauty spas nearby; 24-hour fitness facilities |
| Known for | Wedding and event spaces, marina / Dock & Dine program, river views | Lower Manhattan location, Thompson boutique styling, neighborhood access |
| Event & meeting space | 9,000+ sq ft of flexible waterfront meeting and event space (Ballroom, Promenade, Navesink Room) | Banquet hall and meeting services published; smaller footprint than Molly Pitcher Inn for large outdoor events |
| Parking | Complimentary self-parking plus free valet listed | Valet parking available (surcharge); covered/secured parking listed |
Molly Pitcher Inn sits on the Navesink River with easy walking access to downtown Red Bank theaters and parks.
Choose Molly Pitcher Inn for a quieter waterfront base with local culture and boating options.
Gild Hall is located at 15 Gold Street in Lower Manhattan, steps from Wall Street and Seaport attractions.
Choose Gild Hall for short walks to major Lower Manhattan landmarks and easy city mobility.
Molly Pitcher Inn offers 106 rooms with a classic, colonial-inspired feel and a handful of room types.
Rooms skew classic and comfortable; confirm elevator access and exact room location when booking.
Gild Hall lists about 130 guestrooms across multiple room and suite categories.
Gild Hall offers a larger selection of small, design-forward room types—good for city stays where room variety matters.
Molly Pitcher Inn centers dining around The Dining Room and the International Bar with river views.
Pick Molly Pitcher Inn for classic riverside dining, weekend brunches and event catering.
Gild Hall’s supplier listing highlights Felice Restaurante plus a bar/lounge and limited room service.
Choose Gild Hall if you want in-hotel dining with quick access to a dense downtown restaurant scene.
Molly Pitcher Inn’s signature amenity is its marina and seasonal outdoor pool overlooking the water.
Molly Pitcher Inn is the clear pick for on-site boating and a summertime pool experience.
Gild Hall does not publish an on-site pool and focuses on city convenience rather than waterfront amenities.
Gild Hall is for city-centric travelers who prioritize location over resort-style water amenities.
Molly Pitcher Inn offers a 24-hour fitness center and a calmer evening scene tied to dining and live piano.
Molly Pitcher Inn serves guests who want fitness access and relaxed evening dining music rather than a busy nightlife.
Gild Hall has 24-hour fitness facilities and sits in a neighborhood with bars and late-night options.
Gild Hall fits travelers who want a city fitness option and quick access to Manhattan nightlife.

Molly Pitcher Inn — extensive waterfront event spaces, Promenade for outdoor ceremonies and ballrooms sized for large receptions.

Gild Hall — steps from Wall Street, South Street Seaport and the Oculus for business and sightseeing.

Molly Pitcher Inn — on-site 72-slip marina with Dock & Dine and pool access for docked guests.

Gild Hall — Thompson-branded boutique aesthetic with an upscale downtown hotel experience.
Molly Pitcher Inn — family-friendly rooms, a seasonal outdoor pool and waterfront activities make it a stronger fit for families.
Gild Hall — it’s in the Financial District within walking distance of Wall Street, South Street Seaport and transit links.
Neither property publishes an on-site full-service spa; both list nearby spa options that can be booked separately.
Molly Pitcher Inn offers complimentary self-parking and free valet; Gild Hall lists covered/secured parking and valet for a surcharge.
Explore how Molly Pitcher Inn stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·