
Molly Pitcher Inn
Best for riverfront views, small- to mid-size waterfront weddings, and a quiet Jersey Shore–adjacent getaway.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Molly Pitcher Inn is a historic, riverside boutique hotel in Red Bank, New Jersey, with marina access, a seasonal outdoor pool, and family-friendly services. Hilton Brooklyn Downtown NYC is a full-service, 4-star Hilton in central Downtown Brooklyn aimed at business and city travelers; read this if you’re choosing between a quieter waterfront New Jersey stay and a centrally located Brooklyn base.
Updated

Best for riverfront views, small- to mid-size waterfront weddings, and a quiet Jersey Shore–adjacent getaway.

Best for central Brooklyn access, business travel, and Hilton-brand full-service amenities in a city setting.
When Molly Pitcher Inn wins: choose Molly Pitcher Inn if you want a smaller, historic property with marina access, seasonal outdoor pool and an event focus for weddings or waterfront functions; it’s better for families and guests wanting a quieter riverside stay near Red Bank attractions.
When Hilton Brooklyn Downtown NYC wins: pick Hilton Brooklyn Downtown NYC if you need a centrally located Brooklyn hotel with a large room count, executive/meeting facilities, on-site dining (Carne by Allora) and easy access to Manhattan and Brooklyn cultural sites like Brooklyn Bridge and Barclays Center.
Bottom line: both hotels host meetings and events, but they serve different trip types — Molly Pitcher Inn for waterfront, event-driven or leisure stays near the Jersey Shore; Hilton Brooklyn Downtown NYC for full-service urban stays and commercial travel in central Brooklyn.
| Category | Molly Pitcher Inn | Hilton Brooklyn Downtown NYC |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Classic, colonial-inspired boutique inn on the Navesink River with historic 1928 character | Contemporary full-service urban Hilton, business- and event-oriented |
| Location | Red Bank, NJ waterfront; walkable to theaters, parks, and downtown shops | Downtown Brooklyn; within walking distance of Brooklyn Bridge, BAM, Barclays Center |
| Size (rooms) | 106 guestrooms and suites | 196 air-conditioned rooms |
| Ages / audience | Family-friendly; children of all ages welcome | All-ages hotel; children 12 and under stay free with an adult when using existing bedding |
| Pools | Seasonal outdoor pool overlooking the marina (open in warmer months) | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | The Dining Room (Contemporary American) + International Bar; river-view dining and weekend brunch | Carne by Allora (Italian) + 1 bar/lounge; room service and buffet breakfast (surcharge) |
| Spa & wellness | No on-site spa; 24-hour fitness center with Nautilus and cardio equipment | 24-hour fitness center; health/beauty spas listed nearby (on-site spa not published) |
| Known for | Waterfront event spaces, marina (72 slips), wedding venues and river views | Central Brooklyn location, conference space (1740 sq ft) and Hilton service |
| Parking | Complimentary self-parking and free valet parking for guests | Self parking and valet available for a surcharge (published fees apply) |
| Accessibility & services | Wheelchair accessible public areas; 24-hour front desk; complimentary Wi‑Fi | |
Molly Pitcher Inn sits on the Navesink River in downtown Red Bank, offering riverside walks and local theater within a short walk.
Choose Molly Pitcher Inn for a quieter waterfront base close to Red Bank nightlife and river activities.
Hilton Brooklyn Downtown NYC is centrally located in Downtown Brooklyn, convenient for business, transit and city sightseeing.
Pick Hilton Brooklyn Downtown NYC for a city-center location that simplifies access to Brooklyn and Manhattan.
Molly Pitcher Inn offers a smaller set of classically furnished rooms with four named room types.
Rooms are intimate and historic—good for travelers who prefer boutique character over modern high-rise rooms.
Hilton Brooklyn Downtown NYC has a larger, standardized room inventory with many accessible and executive options.
Hilton offers variety and business-oriented room types—choose it when you want consistent service levels and executive amenities.
Molly Pitcher Inn centers dining around The Dining Room and the International Bar with river views.
If river-view meals and a classic dining room are important, Molly Pitcher Inn is tailored to that experience.
Hilton Brooklyn Downtown NYC has an on-site Italian restaurant and bar plus room service.
Hilton suits travelers who want convenient on-site city-style dining and service for meetings.
Molly Pitcher Inn’s signature amenity is its waterfront setting and seasonal outdoor pool overlooking the marina.
The pool and marina make Molly Pitcher Inn a good pick for boating guests and seasonal leisure stays.
Hilton Brooklyn Downtown NYC emphasizes meeting and conference facilities along with a 24-hour fitness center.
Hilton is stronger for meetings and all-day business amenities rather than waterfront leisure features.
Molly Pitcher Inn provides a 24-hour fitness center and on-site evening dining and entertainment.
Expect basic wellness facilities and a pleasant evening scene with live music but no dedicated spa on site.
Hilton Brooklyn Downtown NYC offers a 24-hour fitness center and is surrounded by Brooklyn nightlife and cultural venues.
Hilton is convenient for guests who want to access Brooklyn nightlife and culture after daytime meetings.

Molly Pitcher Inn — riverfront Promenade, marina and multiple ballroom/meeting options for 10–300 guests.

Hilton Brooklyn Downtown NYC — within walking distance of Brooklyn Bridge, BAM and Barclays Center.

Molly Pitcher Inn — seasonal outdoor pool, marina activities and family-friendly dining.

Hilton Brooklyn Downtown NYC — larger room inventory, conference space and executive-room options.
Molly Pitcher Inn — it offers a Ballroom and promenade with tenting that support up to 300 guests and multiple event rooms.
Hilton Brooklyn Downtown NYC — central location, conference space and executive room options make it more suitable for business travel.
No — neither property is all-inclusive; meals are charged separately (Molly Pitcher Inn offers on-site dining; Hilton lists buffet breakfast for a surcharge).
No — Molly Pitcher Inn does not allow pets, though ADA-defined service animals are welcome.
Explore how Molly Pitcher Inn stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·